A political firestorm has erupted inside the Republican Party as lawmakers lash out against a secretive new health care proposal backed by President Donald Trump. Critics across the conservative spectrum are calling the plan “Obamacare-lite,” arguing that it fails to deliver the full repeal of the Affordable Care Act that the GOP has promised voters for more than a decade.
According to senior Republican aides and leaked draft details, the proposal attempts to restructure the U.S. health insurance system by shifting federal subsidies into tax credits and personal health accounts. While Trump has privately promoted the plan as a bold and market-driven overhaul, many Republicans say it preserves too much of the existing Affordable Care Act framework—undermining conservative priorities and betraying key campaign commitments.
The proposal would redirect traditional ACA subsidies into Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) or Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs), allowing individuals to purchase private insurance more directly. It also aims to scale back federal spending on Medicaid, particularly in states that expanded coverage under the ACA. But the most controversial element is what the plan keeps: protections for pre-existing conditions and provisions allowing young adults to remain on their parents’ insurance until age 26. These features are popular with voters but deeply unpopular among hardline conservatives.
Prominent members of the House Freedom Caucus have condemned the proposal, warning that it amounts to a cosmetic rewrite of Obamacare rather than the structural overhaul Republicans have long demanded. Outside advocacy groups—including FreedomWorks and Club for Growth—have gone even further, branding the proposal a “shallow imitation” of government-run health care. These organizations wield considerable influence among grassroots conservatives, and their opposition signals a major challenge for GOP leadership.
Policy analysts also warn that the plan could destabilize the insurance market. By encouraging healthier Americans to buy cheaper, less comprehensive coverage through HSAs, the proposal risks leaving sicker and older individuals in a shrinking, increasingly expensive insurance pool. Several experts predict this could trigger a slow collapse of current ACA marketplaces, putting millions at risk of losing affordable coverage.
The political timing adds even more pressure. With ACA subsidy extensions set to expire and Republicans racing to deliver on their long-standing pledge to replace Obamacare, the party is under intense scrutiny. A failed plan could reinforce long-running criticism that Republicans have never developed a viable alternative—despite years of promises.
Meanwhile, moderates in the party worry that embracing a deeply divisive proposal could become a liability in upcoming elections. They argue that a full repeal without a strong replacement risks alienating suburban and independent voters, particularly those who rely on ACA protections.
Caught between ideological conservatives demanding a complete teardown of the ACA and pragmatists urging caution, GOP leaders now face a difficult balancing act. Trump’s influence remains powerful, but even his backing may not be enough to unite a fractured Republican caucus around a plan many see as too weak—or too risky—to support.
Watch video below :
